Innovation, Art, and Recognition
An artist's job is to make great art, whether it is recognized in its time or not. Recognition is just one part of creation. Many profound works have been recognized late, and this has ALWAYS been the case. I'm writing this as encouragement for all of the artists who are still waiting for their recognition. Recognition does not define the quality of one's work.
A Story Of Early Innovation
In the 1990s, when we were all carrying beepers instead of mobile phones (if you've never heard of such things... look it up... it was a thing!), the watchmaker Seiko came out with something very cool: the Seiko MessageWatch. It was a beeper on your wrist. You could send notes to it from a desktop computer, like texting, and get the news, sports scores, and stock prices right on your wrist. What an innovation!
My husband, who has always been a techie, bought us both MessageWatches. We would "text" each other on our watches before texting was a thing.
The world wasn't ready. Many people thought a watch should just be a watch. A couple of years later, the MessageWatch was discontinued, the service stopped, and it went away. Now look at everyone's wrists. The idea was right. The timing wasn't. In business, this can be seen as a misstep; in art, it is the seed of creative expansion.
All innovation can be ahead of its time... and art is no exception. Some great works are celebrated in their own moment, and some take time to be fully seen. I thought I'd take a moment to explore that.
The Painters
In the 1880s, while Vincent van Gogh was painting, the art world belonged to William-Adolphe Bouguereau, whose polished paintings of mythology and idealized country life sold for fortunes at the Paris Salon. Here's the twist: Van Gogh's brother Theo was an art dealer in Paris, and a good one. He was one of the first to champion Monet and Degas. The one painter he could never sell was his own brother. Vincent sold just one painting in his lifetime that we know of for sure. Within a few decades, as tastes shifted, Bouguereau's name became shorthand for stuffy, sentimental art, and in the years after his death, Van Gogh became one of the most beloved painters who ever lived. Can you imagine if he had stopped painting because he went unrecognized? Think of the masterpieces the whole world loves that we would never have known.
Two centuries earlier, Johannes Vermeer painted slowly and carefully in Delft, while Gerrit Dou of Leiden was the superstar of Dutch art, so sought after that Queen Christina of Sweden's agent paid him a yearly fee just to see his new work first. When Vermeer died at 43, deep in debt, his widow handed two of his paintings to the local baker to cover the BREAD BILL (mind-blowing). For generations, his work was sometimes sold under other painters' names (his masterpiece The Art of Painting even carried a fake Pieter de Hooch signature) until a French critic rediscovered him in 1866, nearly two centuries after his death. That same decade, Dou's prices finally began to fall.
This isn't about which art is good or bad, only which was recognized and which wasn't. Today, Vermeer's Girl with a Pearl Earring is one of the most recognizable paintings in the world. It even inspired a movie of the same name, starring Scarlett Johansson and Colin Firth. Yet in his own time, Vermeer was largely invisible beyond Delft. Can you imagine if he had stopped painting because he was not widely known and celebrated? What a tremendous loss that would be.
The Composers
In 1723, the city of Leipzig needed a new music director. Their first choice, Georg Philipp Telemann, the most celebrated composer in Germany, used the offer to get a raise at home. Their second choice couldn't get out of his contract. So they settled for their third choice: Johann Sebastian Bach. One councilman reportedly grumbled that if they couldn't have the best, they'd have to settle for the mediocre. Bach stayed 27 years and wrote music almost every week. Even at the height of his career, a well-known critic called his music "turgid and confused," too complicated for modern ears. After he died, he was remembered mostly as a fine organist and teacher, and his great works sat on the shelf until 1829, nearly 80 years later, when a 20-year-old Felix Mendelssohn conducted the St. Matthew Passion in Berlin and the world woke up.
Telemann, by the way, is an example of a genius who was recognized in his own time. That's the reality for some great artists, and we celebrate them too! But I'm here to encourage the artists who are doing all they can to keep making their art in a world that doesn't yet fully understand their effort and their value.
In 1820s Vienna, all anyone could talk about was Rossini. "Rossini fever" was the superstar craze of its day. Franz Schubert, meanwhile, lived in friends' spare rooms and never heard his great symphonies played in public. (And he loved Rossini! No shade to his celebrated contemporary. Schubert even wrote two overtures "in the Italian style.") He died at 31. Ten years later, Robert Schumann found a stack of unknown manuscripts at Schubert's brother's home, including a huge symphony that a Vienna orchestra had passed on as too long and too hard. Mendelssohn (again!) premiered it in 1839. And the "Unfinished" Symphony sat in a friend's desk drawer for more than 40 years. It wasn't heard until 1865.
Sometimes it doesn't take centuries. In 1913, Igor Stravinsky's The Rite of Spring premiered in Paris to boos, catcalls and shouting in the aisles. The reaction was so big that opening night became legendary. People still describe it as a riot, scuffles and all. Less than a year later, at a concert performance in Paris, the audience carried Stravinsky out on their shoulders.
Today's Test
This morning the Grammy nominations were announced. Some of my favorite projects were among the nominees, and I'm genuinely thrilled for them—while other albums I deeply admire didn't make the list. Art isn't a sport, so awards will always capture only a fraction of the great work being made.
My own album, DELIGHTFULLY, was among those not recognized. I didn't know how I would feel... but honestly? I feel OK.
I know WHY I make my art, and it's not for awards or even industry recognition (though that would be nice! And sure would make life easier).
Every independent artist pouring heart and soul into the work, myself included, shares the same job: to make the best art we can, and then do it again and again and again, improving with every project. For me, as a self-funded independent artist, that also means getting creative about how to fund and promote my projects. It's a very good thing I'm rich in creativity.
Art that pushes forward often asks listeners to feel and think differently than they have before—and the industry's taste at any given moment is just a snapshot, not the whole story. Tastes change. It can take decades, or even centuries, for certain work to find its widest audience. In the meantime, if your art is enriching people, even just a few in its own time, it is doing powerful service.
That's why it matters so much for artists to stay true to their aesthetic, their voice and their spiritual leadings, and to create the way they are led to, whether the work is understood and celebrated in its moment or lost (temporarily) in it. Art is a vehicle for transcendence, and great art will always have something of the mysterious in it. Maybe that's why it can take the world a while to catch up.
And the Seiko MessageWatch? Let it be a reminder. Don't give up! Your innovation may just be ahead of its time. Own it!
I say this to encourage those of us who have dedicated our lives to creating incandescent art. Innovation and art are full of rejection and disappointment. The best thing we can do as artists and innovators is to keep bringing our ideas to life, and go further and harder toward them.
The world would be a far less vibrant place if Van Gogh, Vermeer, Bach, Schubert or Stravinsky, or the countless artists whose names we may never know but whose work still shaped the world around them, had stopped creating because their world couldn't yet see what was right in front of them.
I'm content to let time be the judge. My job is just to keep making the work, and to keep improving on the version of myself that stepped into the studio or onto the stage yesterday. My purpose is to make art that serves, and to get it as far out into the world as I can, reaching as many people as possible.
So to all of us who are soldiering on against the odds, keep going. Keep making the thing only you can make. I'll do the same!
Always with love, Monika



Comments